The Pinnable Life: What Do Your Pins Say About You?

pinme

Ever since its creation, the social media site Pinterest has been the target of both celebration and derision amongst the creative community. The site, which allows you to digitally “pin” inspirational photographs to virtual bulletin boards, has become an immensely popular tool among everybody from home bloggers to brides-to-be, a streamlined and easy way to bookmark, collect, and showcase imagery. It has been hailed as the savior of the creative internet and, simultaneously, lambasted as its worst enemy. Depending on who you ask, Pinterest can either be viewed as an essential research tool and community builder or an evil, copyright-infringing menace to the professional creative. These arguments have already been made with more depth and eloquence than I could ever muster, so I’m going to leave them to the professionals. (If you’re interested, just google Pinterest and copyright.) What I’m curious about, and what this short article will discuss, is the social function that Pinterest fulfills. As our social lives move increasingly into the digital realm, many social functions that previously lived in the physical world are now finding parallels online. Twitter and Facebook, for example, act in much the same way that postcards and face-to-face chats did in the previous century. What social void does Pinterest fill, though? What does the act of “pinning” say about us as humans and as a society? Let’s discuss.

You’re reading this website, so I’m going to go ahead and assume that you are, at least somewhat, interested in design. And as somebody who is interested in design (and aesthetics), you likely also have what some might call a “personal style.” This personal style—whatever that might mean—very well may inform many of your aesthetic choices, from how you choose to dress and decorate your apartment, right down to the type of toothbrush you buy. Everybody, it can be argued, has a kind of personal style—a certain grouping of aesthetic choices that, when combined, create a visual sense of self. What is the purpose of these personal styles, though, and why do we choose them? Upbringing, and the places, people, and things that we live with most definitely influence our style. As, of course, do personal preferences. “I just like it,” you might say to the person who asks why you have chosen to wear nothing but black your entire life. Indeed, “liking” something is oftentimes the most logical and obvious rationale for your chosen personal style. But is that the entire story?

Let us imagine, for the sake of this discussion, that the entire human race (aside from yourself) has been obliterated by a worldwide zombie apocalypse. You are the last human being alive on earth. Do you, as the sole survivor of the zombie takeover, have a “personal style?” Do you continue to decorate your apartment with beautiful objects or wear clothing that you think represents who you are? You are, of course, preoccupied with survival and outrunning zombies, so nobody will blame you for a certain lack of decorum. Still—do you think that, without anybody around, you will continue to cultivate and express the same aesthetic, stylistic choices? I’m going to go out on a limb and say no. You may stop to admire a lovely spring blossom, but I doubt you’re going to pluck it up and turn it into a floral crown while fighting for your life.

personalstylesquote

As much as we like to imagine that our personal styles are about us as individuals, something that defines who we are at our core, our personal styles would be nothing without the people around us. The material objects that we use to fill our homes and adorn our bodies are no different from most other man-made objects—they are, after fulfilling their primary function, communicative tools. The primary function of a pair of shoes, for instance, is to protect one’s feet. When we go out shoe-shopping, however, foot protection oftentimes takes a backseat to style—what will these shoes say about me as a person? Depending on the shoes’ cost, visible markings, material, color, and overall design they might “say” any number of things. These shoes, as with the rest of one’s personal style, help us to “perform” a certain version of ourselves to onlookers within the proverbial theater of life. They are, in a sense, part of a costume.

What makes the you of today different from the you of the zombie apocalypse? Other people. The social need to perform and wear such a “costume” is eliminated due to the fact that any people who would have previously been around to witness it are now rotting, walking corpses. We might all believe that our personal styles are somewhat innate—born with us and “curated” as part of a unique desire to appeal to our own senses. Although this may be at least partially true, it is certainly not the entire picture. Whether we want to admit it or not, our impulse to acquire objects to wear and ornament our personal spaces has much more to do with the people who will see them than us personally. In a way, we define ourselves not by our personal styles, but how our personal styles are perceived by other people. This perception is what helps to inform our sense of self and our place within society. And this—this impulse to mold people’s perceptions—seems to be what is at the core of our desire to pin.

On paper, Pinterest is marketed as a tool for bookmarking and accessing images that you find inspiring—an online bulletin board, so to speak. Bulletin boards, and the desire to save and surround ourselves with images that we find personally inspiring, have been around for ages. Pinterest, though, has taken this heretofore private act and made it public, through the twenty-first century concept of social media. Like Facebook, Twitter, and Instagram, Pinterest is yet another tool for sharing things with friends and the world at large. The thing that separates Pinterest from the rest of its social media ilk, though, is that, by and large, the things that we share on it are not our own. Pinterest isn’t used to post selfies or status updates pertaining to one’s own life. It is used, almost exclusively, as a tool for “acquiring” objects (in this case, intangible images) that project a certain sense of self. In direct defiance of Pinterest’s terms of service (which stipulate that you are the rights holder to all images posted), the grand majority of the images uploaded to people’s Pinterest boards are from external sources: catalogues, interior design blogs, artist portfolios, and Flickr streams. The result is a digital, entirely non-physical manifestation of our desire to craft a personal style—public collections that communicate who we are, what we like, and how we want to be perceived.

In Renaissance Europe, the homes of the social and economic elite often featured rooms that housed personal  collections. Known as Kunstkammers (German for “art room”) these curiosity cabinets stored travel souvenirs, hunting trophies, exotic naturalia, and art that was commissioned by the room’s owner. These so-called “wonder rooms” are oftentimes considered the precursor to the modern museum—they functioned as viewing spaces and were oftentimes used to entertain visitors to the home. In addition to providing entertainment, though, these rooms also helped their owners to project their own “personal style” and wealth to a select public. The objects on display, culled from expensive travels and far-off locales, functioned as status markers. “I have excellent taste,” says an oil painting. “I can afford to have leisure time,” says a mounted tortoise shell. “The Kunstkammer was regarded as a microcosm or theater of the world, and a memory theater,” writes Art Historian Francesca Fiorani in a 1998 Renaissance Quarterly article. “The Kunstkammer conveyed symbolically the patron’s control of the world through its indoor, microscopic reproduction.”

kunstkammerquote

In a way, Pinterest boards are the twenty-first century’s version of the Renaissance Kunstkammer—with one massive difference. While a Kunstkammer was meant to project a patron’s style and wealth (they did, after all, invest great capital into the objects housed within it), a Pinterest board allows one to project one’s style for free, thereby avoiding the need for unattainable wealth. In this respect, Pinterest could be viewed as a democratizer of sorts—it allows anybody (or at least anybody with a computer and an internet connection) to “collect” and display objects and art, all tell-tale markers of taste and social status, without financial investment. You may be a college student that lives in a non-furnished dorm room, but your Pinterest boards, filled with designer furniture and bookmarked DIY-projects, tell a story of who you want to be and what your style (not your current spending power) is. You might not be able to afford those Marc Jacobs shoes, but by pinning them, you let the world know that if you could, they are what you would wear. Granted, there are arguments to be made against this money-free form of intangible consumerism and its dark, copyright-infringing underbelly, but all of that aside—one can not deny that the creation and popularity of Pinterest has created a fascinating development in the culture of the “personal style.” Whereas in previous years, much of one’s personal style was dictated by the weight of one’s wallet, Pinterest allows us to bypass this hurdle and cultivate style through a simple click of the mouse.

There is a reason that Pinterest is social and not a private bookmarking service—and it pretty much comes down to our aforementioned zombie-apocalypse-scenario. Would Pinterest be the monolithic internet superpower that it is today if it didn’t allow you to share your pins with the public? Would you continue to nurture your personal style if you were the last person on earth? The answer to both of these seemingly disparate but not necessarily unrelated questions is probably not. As members of Pinterest, we use our pins to archive inspiration, yes. But we also use them to project an image of who we think we are—to say something about ourselves. So— some food for thought: Why do you pin? What do your pins say about you?

whatdoyourpinssay

Kreative Kristina

I found this article to be very interesting. As an active Pinterest user, it made me think more about what I am actually spending my time on and what sort of image I am projecting, while I am curating my own style publicly. Thanks for the new perspective on my favorite form of social media!

Laura

Whoa! This strikes me as quite cynical. I assume that no one has ever given more than a passing glance to my thousand or so pins. If they do, it has to do with the pin itself, not me. That’s less true for “celebrity” pinners who have a “brand” to cultivate, sure. But 95% of pinners are functionally anonymous. Pinterest IS social. We are sharing images and ideas, but it’s about the images an ideas, NOT the people doing the pinning.

Emily R

So timely. Recently in MA a teacher was killed. It was a terrible tragedgy and has reached national news. In their effort to put together who she was they have gone and taken snippets from her facebook, twitter account and pinterest account. It saddens me that this has become “her” to a national audience. I personally don’t have a pinterest account. It doesn’t fill a need for me. But I do think whether or not you want your pinterest page to be a reflection of yourself or not, those viewing it decide for themselves what it reflects, not you.

Mokhe

I enjoyed this, thank you. It struck me more as realism than cynicism.

Ann

I appreciated this article. I think that this viewpoint of pinterest is probably held by many. I do think however, that my use of pinterest is very different? My biggest frustration with pinterest is the social aspect. I use pinterest heavily to pin products that I like, but am not ready to purchase quite yet. As I’m remodeling my bathroom, living room…etc., I’m able to view all of the products that I want to purchase and see them together as a type of inspiration board. Frankly, I don’t want my friends to have access to this information. I don’t want them to come over knowing that my light fixture cost $300, or the new sweater I’m wearing was full price. I realize that the social aspect of pinterest (as you noted) is what drives it’s popularity, but this is my least favorite aspect of the site. Maybe my desire for privacy is also driven by my need for approval. i.e.- my friends will think more highly of me if they think I don’t care about pinterest and have cultivated my style without any help? I did enjoy this article however, because it dives into why we do what we do! I think that my “personal style” is less personal than I realize. Also, as I’m decorating my home, I’m not just considering me and my husband’s style, but also how our style will be perceived by friends and family. I don’t think the article is cynical at all. It’s good to step back and think about our intentions from time to time, and get a better view of ways we can change and grow!

Jill

I agree that any form of social media is about projecting an image. While I do use Pinterest as more of a storehouse (for recipes, workouts, items I’m interested in buying) of information, I also pin quotes, outfits, and other more aspirational items that both inspire me and are something I feel an “audience” would enjoy. Giving deeper thought to our social media and our actions online isn’t cynical–I think it’s smart.

Carly

This article was excellent, I lol’d at the flower crown part. It definitely got me thinking about my personal style and how much of it is really what I like or how much of it is actually what I think others may like or approve of. Now I’m going to go pin…

Lauren J @ The Barn

This was fascinating for me to read. Very thought provoking. I’ve always thought of the way I dress to be an expression of my style and creativity, but recently I began working from home again and I realize that my motivation to get dressed it totally driven by others. On that tangent, and applicable to the above, although I love Pinterest, I recently got a little bored with it because the same pins showed up time and time again, which only reenforces the already known fact that everyone wants a big beautiful home, fancy clothes, smart kids, and the ability to craft a masterpiece out of straws and a paperclip. The more people that are on it, the more “mainstream” it seems to become. I miss the days when there were just a few of us on there and everything was so “new!”

Clarissa

As someone who’s a freelancer and building my business/audience, I’ve taken a thought in how and what I pin. My Pinterest is linked to my blog and eventually my website (when it’s up).

It’s not that I’m trying to hide who I am, but for me, there are certain things I won’t pin even if I agree for misc reasons: might be too offense, it doesn’t fit my business brand, etc.

I think it depends on how you use your Pinterest boards. It’s different strokes for different folks.

Thanks for this post!

Danielle

Wow, what a fascinating and thought-provoking analysis! THANK YOU. Being as I probably only pin 1/5 of my Pinterest board and depend on other pinners I adore (like you guys!) for the rest of the re-pins, I completely agree with you that the platform is social. To be honest, I pin as an individual because it’s free and at this moment in time I cannot tangibly surround myself with such beautiful objects. It also serves an inspiration board as I navigate through life and try to maintain a certain level of joie de vivre on my road to “success”… whatever that means ;)

karen

I only use Pinterest for bookmarking mainly recipes and photography ideas, not necessarily to make myself look good.

Jaimi

To be known and identified as an individual is our most inherent human desire, I think Pinterest fulfills that in most people. As a designer, I definitely have a love hate relationship with Pintrest as, more often than not, it discourages my own creativity rather than encouraging a spark of creativity. I get stuck on what others have done well instead of concentrating on the creative project at hand.

HB

Thanks for this! I take whatever I pin very seriously, probably more than I should. It surprises me sometimes what other people pin. I admittedly live off of Pinterest, not only for hoping it will enhance my life but also help me in my work environment. Seeing these “pins” and my boards everyday gives me a sense of fulfillment (even if I havent even scratched the surface of my DIY board). Since I surround myself with inspiration and ideas all day, I want to make sure my boards aren’t cluttered with unsightly pins.

Heather

Interesting. I think I tend use my boards mainly for my own reference, but I am conscious of the public nature and am probably more thoughtful about what I pin as a result. In some cases, though, pinning something I know I could not or should not indulge in, maybe somehow helps to satisfy a desire to acquire? Its a safe place to “hoard” without cluttering up real space.

LW

Interesting. I find pinterest to be the least social of social media, which is why i LIKE it, haha. I feel less pressure to follow my facebook friends on pinterest and really focus on following people who have similar taste-the vast majority of whom I do not know or interact with on any level (other than repinning their images, I guess).
I often find that if I see things on pinterest I want to share, then it goes on my tumblr – that is where I do more “sharing” of myself and things I like. But everyone uses these things differently.
Also, when I pin food, it is strictly for bookmarking purposes. When I feel like cooking it’s much easier to flip through my pinterest food board than to figure out which recipes i’ve printed off and where they went and what was emailed to myself or whatever.
Thanks for the thought-provoking article!

Sarah @ Mocha

What a thought provoking piece! I think that even though we have have our own personal style, it’s always going to be influenced by the people around us. That’s the nature of design (and art) to be inspired by different ideas and people and combine aspects of those different influences to come up with something new.

As for why we pin. By the very nature of it being social, a lot of it is to do with sharing passions. So perhaps it’s less about trying to project an image of who we think we are. Rather, more of a desire to share things we find beautiful or inspiring with others and make it a shared experience.

JC Carter

I pin because it boosts the number of views to my blog. I pin all of my posts, and recipes which are then viewed by others. I feel that by also pinning additional things, such as outfits, quotes, fitness inspiration, crafts and home projects I am allowing my readers to get to know me better, and hopefully enticing them to follow my blog and check out my shop. This is all to boost a certain outward persona however. I am careful not to pin off color humor, or pins that can be misconstrued however, so I would have to say that my “pin-persona” (Pinsona?) is not really that close to my real true personality.

Great Article!!

Keri Muller

Pinterest is escapism – like most online social media platforms. When you feel a little under-par it’s much easier to go and look at lovely things that require no personal input except to arrange (read: pin) them. Instead, one should be picking up a pen and drawing OR going for a stroll OR just sitting and thinking quietly about everything and nothing.

But that’s what drives me mad about the world right now – social media makes us more insular, rather than more open to what is really happening around us.

Daniella

Interesting thoughts! I agree that people tend to pin the “style” they want to have, but I don’t think it’s just so people think of them in a different way. I genuinely pin what I like personally, not what might make me stylish in the minds of other people. The proof is in the negative comments that pop up to tell you how ugly that dress is that you just pinned, lol. Everyone has a different opinion. I think people are capable of genuinely liking something because it’s beautiful in their mind though, and not necessarily caring what other people think or if they have perfect “style”. The only difference is that it’s public now and up for criticism. If you look at someone’s board that you know personally, it really does reflect the reality of who they are – at least those I know. You might pin $300 shoes you can’t afford, but they’re there for inspiration as you find another pair that are cheaper, but still just as beautiful.

I used to collage in books from magazines, in the same way that I now “pin” to pinterest. No one saw those, but it still reflected my personal style.

Rachel

I have been so thankful to Pinterest for providing a platform which I have used to begin to define my personal style, for myself. I spent a lot of time on Pinterest about a year ago simply repinning the ideas and images that piqued my interest. Now I can look through my boards and see themes of colors and style that carry through DIY, personal fashion, and home decor. I have been so thankful for the many people that I follow that have shared images that I never would have found without their input, but I tend to approach Pinterest as a consumer. As an individual without a blog or business, I have not actively thought about this process creating an image or brand that I am communicating to others. I found this article thought provoking. I wonder what my boards say about me, my priorities, and my style.

kamo

I don’t use Pinterest, but I do frequently use Gimmebar, which is pretty similar. You can snag pictures, text, videos, etc. from any website, and it gets posted to a stream like a Tumblr or Pinterest page. However, my Gimmebar is completely private. I’ve never shown it to anyone and would feel weird if someone saw it, as if they were reading my diary. I mostly post images of architecture, design, fashion, art and photography, people i find intriguing, snippets from books i’ve read, etc. To me it’s very personal and a visual representation of whatever mood I’m going through, where my feelings are informing my current aesthetic interests. I’ve always been a visual person and writing feelings down in a diary has never worked for me, but this does. I can go back and look through it and get both creative inspiration and have a rough timeline of my headspace when I posted everything.

While Pinning IS public and what I do is not, I don’t think stripping the public aspect away would leave it inherently meaningless. I guess I relate to the girl in zombieland, carrying on a bit of her style. If Pinterest is public posturing, maybe what I’m doing is self-posturing? Not sure.

Audrey/ Park St

This article makes me think that the next big thing is going to be people uploading their own photos to Pinterest rather than re-pinning the same photos again and again. What better way to show who you are than to create your own original content?

Katy

I think Pinterest shows me as the social misfit I’ve always suspected I was – I never look at other people’s pins. There, I said it, I’m the worst pinning friend in history… Insanely though, there are several thousand people following me and repinning whatever recipe whims or crafty whims I happened to have pinned, along with random home decor ideas. I think my style probably says ‘should stop eating and sewing so much’ ;)

Taryn

I really like your zombie apocalypse scenario, but it brought this one scene from last season of the walking dead to mind. One of the main characters steals this hideous multi-colored cat statue from a bar in the midst of them fighting off zombies because she likes it and wants to keep it in her room. It was obviously played for laughs after a heavy scene, but as a design lover, I loved the idea of still wanting to decorate your camp with something beautiful (or at least, beautiful to you) when there was so much ugliness in the world. Photo of Michonne and her cat statue here: http://telstarmedia.files.wordpress.com/2013/03/michonnecat.jpg

So that was kind of off topic, but to respond to your main point, yes, pinning is very much an escapist, money-free way to cultivate a personal style and a sense of self. Just like Facebook is a way to cultivate the highlight reel of your life for others to view. I just think it’s a more sub-conscious act than we realize at the time. When we post to Facebook, we aren’t necessarily thinking, “I want to post this so people think I’m so wonderful” and I don’t think we necessarily pin with that intent either. On Facebook, we think about capturing a memory or sharing a photo with a friend. And on Pinterest, we might be thinking about an activity that might make our home more beautiful for the ones we love. In both cases, we’re cultivating others see us, whether intentional or not.

Kelly

I agree 100% that our personal style has more to do with how other people perceive us, and while some have said that is a somewhat cynical view, I don’t think it is at all. We as humans naturally want to express ourselves creatively, and if there is no audience to “perform” to, then there is no point and that desire would not exist.

I work in a design field and, although it kind of sounds shallow, someone’s taste says a lot about them. At my last job, if we were interviewing potential new designers, we would look them up online, including their Pinterest profiles. We could tell right away if someone was going to be a good fit for our company’s aesthetic based on what they themselves liked. It’s seems unfair, but it’s true. Trying to groom someone into our aesthetic seemed like a lot more work than if someone just already had it. Also, to the commenter Clarissa’s point, since I have been on the viewing end of that situation, I am aware that people might be doing the same thing to me. Therefore, I refrain from pinning anything related to religion or politics which are things people have strong opinions about.

Simona

Interesting take. Although I do not agree that I would change my entire wardrobe and walk around like a slob. For me it is all about how the style makes me feel. I wear colorful clothes because the make me happy. When Im alone in my four walls, the style I love, makes me feel comfortable. I guess I’m a bit of a color freak. SO if I were running for my life, I would probablly wear a light pink, to feel calm, hehe.

Jo

It’s a wonder Pinterest can stipulate users only pin images they hold rights to when there is a re-pin button built into the site…

Rose Duggan

Great post. I have a board titled “Books I Want People To Think I Read” for exactly the reasons stated in Max’s peice. I know, on some level, that I’m pinning for the benefit of other people.

Kathy

I actually would prefer it if my Pinterest collections were private. I use them as I used to do with notebooks filled with scraps of paper, sketches, and torn-out images–for MY OWN inspiration and NOT to communicate with others. What I am inspired by them to create, well, that is a different story; that is other-oriented. But the notebooks were just for me: to immerse myself in, be nurtured by, and to enjoy. The convenience and expanded access afforded by Pinterest is unbeatable, but I miss the privacy and concentrated focus on creativity that the “old ways” allowed.

Maxwell Tielman

Hi, Kathy!

I actually use a great website called DropMark (http://dropmark.com) for private “pinning.” It allows you to have unlimited pinboards and they’re all private! I use it all the time when I’m gathering inspiration for D*S posts.

Max

Sandi

I pin for inspiration for our home, how to inspire my kids, enjoy our holidays more, sneak more veggies in our diets, make better cakes and to try to remind myself that I need to think about my style a litte as well. I don’t look for followers or think about what other people think about my choices. That’s not as much fun as a recipe for popcorn ball monsters or fabulous wallpaper.

Maria

Thank you for this thought-provoking article! I came here expecting a cutesy quiz-like article and got some well-researched perspective, instead. I definitely use Pinterest in a social way to show my personality, in addition to my personal research and inspirational usage. To the Pinterest world, I am a dessert addict, and that is not untrue!

Nina

In a zombie apocalypse, I would still put that flower in a vase and make a pretty bouquet just as if Pinterest were not public, I would still pin, like crazy! I understand that there is a social aspect, but I still love beautiful things, no matter what. And, I actually use pinterest as a reference. I often go back and look at boards to spark or reference ideas. There is an element of social-ness, but that’s not what keeps me pinning or choosing uncomfortable shoes! Great food for thought, though! Thank you!

Kay

I see Pinterest as an inevitable outgrowth of a consumer culture. With a glut of products available, an easy way to wade through them is to follow others with similar taste. It can be like having a personal shopper, directing you toward products you’ll probably like. I use blogs, including this one, in a similar way. I give no thought to others’ opinions about my pins. One of my most used boards is a private one for collecting gift ideas. When a birthday rolls around, I find I’ve already pinned the perfect gift and don’t have to go through the hassle of shopping.

As for the zombie apocalypse scenario, there’s PLENTY of prepper/survivalist how-to pins being shared! You’re thinking too narrowly about Pinterest, Maxwell. It’s not just used to cultivate an aesthetic, it’s also used to share knowledge. Assuming we all had wifi during said apocalypse, I might refer to my “Skills” board and remind myself how to start a fire, skin a deer, or purify water. If I were feeling social, I could even pin something I found useful as a way to help the other survivors.

Products and skills are two categories of pins, and my third is inspiration for a future need. As a graphic designer, I pin others’ work and refer back to it in the same way that I used to flip through design books to jumpstart my creativity. This has nothing to do with social perceptions and is purely for my own benefit at work. Again, you think too narrowly about Pinterest. It’s not all clothes and pretension and self-promotion.

Suzonne

I must respectfully disagree with this perspective, though it is an interesting argument. I participated in the very first Pinterest campaign, Pin It Forward. I remember putting together that first board and it was a bit intimidating – like standing on the lawn in your underwear. THAT felt like a showcase, an announcement to the world. But I continued to use Pinterest and began to love it more and more. I have just one rule – pin only what I really, really love. Period. I can honestly say that I don’t pay attention to what it says about me or what I might be projecting. But I do get immense pleasure from looking at those compilations of images (much as I did when I collected tearsheets as a child). Also, as someone who works from home – very few people see my home from day to day. But it’s condition – whether it’s cluttered, artfully arranged, chaotic or serene – those things affect me mentally. I collect and curate for myself, both on Pinterest and off.

Mrs Eden

I’m an art teacher and I pin for my class projects. It helps me organise my teaching inspiration. I get a lot of repins from this account. I guess because people are looking to make things and i’m good at finding those because that’s my job.

I also have a personal account. At first I didn’t even want to use my name to “own” the account and then I did because I wanted to connect (socialise) with my friends. I think it would only be friends who look at my boards.

The boards are a reflection of me. They are aspirational but also inspirational and reflective.

I’d rather pin something that I’m into right now than make a status update on FB.

Clare

Interesting. I thought I was the only one pinning ‘privately.’ I don’t engage with the social aspects at all. For me it’s a way to group items from disparate sources together, so I can readily see compare/ remember them for later purchase. With a few ‘inspiration’ pics when I was renovating, though some of them were not inspiring in the traditional sense (hideous bathroom, but adequately shows the shade of grout I’m considering…).

Tara

This was a very interesting article; thank you for opening a conversation about it! As a tumblr and Pinterest member, I think I fall in to the category of NOT liking the social media aspect of it. I actually stopped using tumblr because it felt like most of the people I was following stopped posting what they liked and started posting things that would simply gain more followers. In my experience, Pinterest is more about an automatic response to curating beauty and less of a branding opportunity. It took me a while to jump on the bandwagon and use it and only gave in because I had been saving images from all over the web to my macbook iphoto and my memory couldn’t take it anymore! Maybe it is the type of person I am but I think I’d probably still decorate my little habitat post-zombie apocalypse. I simply couldn’t live without beauty! :)

Zsuzsa

You make some very interesting points. I am not sure about others, but I use Pinterest to organize my ideas and inspirations, and catalogue resources. I can invite others with whom I work on a project to join a certain board and it makes cooperation on a remote project much easier. I recently renovated an apartment on the other side of the world where the easiest way to communicate ideas and list materials and furnishings was creating a Pinterest board. It was so successful, I am using the same method in my next project. With that said, even though I use the site for its functionality, I do not mind having followers. Kinda nice to see that others enjoy some of the beautiful images I pin. :-)

amy

Interesting essay! Perhaps I’m an introverted dinosaur, but I don’t use this particular form of social media in a way that’s, well, very social. I actually do create a lot of the things I pin, or use them for project inspiration. (Perhaps why I don’t have 48,201 pins like a lot of people). It’s a good way to organize my thoughts, and I’ve also been fiddling with getting my blog out on Pinterest to showcase photos & recipes.

One exception to antisocial pinning is using Pinterest to find presents or make things for friends. It’s easy to figure out what they like when you get such a clear visual like a Pinterest board. For instance, all my friends are pregnant (hello, 25!) and I’ve been churning out baby blankets like mad this year. I check friends’ Pinterest accounts to get an idea of their personal style and design from there (be it abstract, cutesey, antique, geometric, etc.).

Miss Heliotrope

I find the responses of people are almost as interesting a representation of pinterest as your interpretation – we all want to think we’re individual. I use it for a miriad of reasons (& yes, feel a little spark of pleasure when someone I dont know from the other side of the world likes or repins one of my pins) – in part, it is that someone else out there likes what I do, unlike most of my family who think my tastes odd.

Pinterest can be an electronic bookmark & list – recipes, christmas presents (a secret board that one), youtube videos that I would like to watch & want to remember. Did no one else use to have a list of sites or images that they looked at regularly just because? Now I dont need a saved word doc, I just pin.

I am not on other social media – I dislike the fake intimacy, but pinterest is not necessarily look at me, but look at this – & yes, it reflects on me that I like these things (the colour green, cats, decor, art, & a scary amount of shoes I would never buy) – but at the same time, it is a collection of pretty things, chosen by me, that I like to look at – I am in very poor health & there are times when just gently browsing images of nice gardens or works of art or cushions is pleasant & undemanding. I dont want to buy most of them, I just think they’re beautiful, and by pinning them, I “own” them as much as I want.

Alex

I know the way I use Pinterest isn’t necessarily the way everyone else does, but for me, it’s my least-social social media site. I like seeing what everyone else has pinned, but I don’t care if anyone looks at mine (and sort of don’t WANT them to… I’d make most of my boards secret if there wasn’t a 3-board limit.) The ideas I’m pinning might ultimately have a social aim, but I want to be judged by the projects I actually complete, not by the random inspiration I’m hoarding.

(Also, re: zombie apocalypse… I’d probably let fashion go to the way side, but provided I wasn’t actively fighting to stay alive, I’d still want an attractive and comfortable home. I don’t invite that many people into my house anyway- the way it looks is for me more than anyone else.)

Claire - Matching Pegs

I’m a bit like the Art teacher above, most of my pins are actually tutorials, techniques, examples or inspiration related to sewing, quilting, applique and embroidery.
It is a way for me to visually organise the content that previously I would have just bookmarked.

I design quilting patterns and patterns for other sewn objects such as softies, and the inspiration I pin is often pieces of art or colour palettes that excite me. I do have a board of interiors that I like, (to consider if we do anything to our house) but don’t pin any clothes or shoes, (unless you count a few garment patterns I have pinned) and I don’t think much about what other people are going to think of my pins.

Kiki

Ha! I think my take on beauty and inspiration is pretty idealistic and romanticized. When I began reading your zombie apocalypse scenario, I found myself thinking “yes! I would totally still collect all things beautiful! Look at any artifacts from a historical site and it will show you that through the ages we’ve valued beauty as a human species!”. Then. The article took a very cynical turn.

I agree with what many others are saying in that my personal use of Pinterest isn’t social…it’s just a place to capture beauty and I wish it was more private! If anything, it allows me more creative brain space to let things go easier. I have this security in knowing that some great discovery is always waiting for me in my boards and I don’t need to hold onto it in my head. Great perspective, thanks for sharing :)

Sarah

I am definitely a pinner who pins for myself, with the exception of one board which contains my DIY projects I want to share. Otherwise, all my boards are for my own use and inspiration (much to the dismay of anyone following me when I will pin a few dozen fabric samples for upcoming projects). I am also very picky with my pins, I guess curating my inspiration deliberately. Now that I have a larger assortment of pins, it is fun to look at a board in its entirety and see themes or connective styles.

Tricia Rose

No! and I think a desert island might be a better theory – you would still try to make it agreeable, and would still exercise ingenuity and choice. Zombies are just too demotivating.

Kristin

Good article. I think I’m like Katy, not a great social pinner, a social misfit. I don’t follow anyone, and I’m assuming most people who follow me on Pinterest do so because they read, and like, the content of my blog. I’m sure they are disappointed by my lack of pins.

I try to use it occasionally, but it overwhelms me to be honest, so I avoid it. The irony is that I get a good deal of traffic to my blog from people coming over from images others have pinned from my site. For that reason I feel bad that I’m not a huge fan, but in the end, I’m not sure it’s increased actual readership that much, just visitors. I love blogs with good writing, and I think it’s a strength of my own. Good writing isn’t pinned, images are.

Speaking of good writing, I’m enjoying D*S’s lately. Thank you.

Kristin

What an interest article! I never thought of Pinterest like that. I only got into it recently as away to watch what my favorite blogs post. I agree, it’s more about other people then yours when it comes to the images. Also it’s much more enjoyable to share what you like and have others like them back.

EllieA

I enjoyed the analysis of this excellent essay, especially the apt comparison to the kunstkammer. Thank you, Maxwell. As other commenters have noted I tried out the ideas outlined on my own pinning habits and must admit that I am pleased when one of my (not original) pins is repined (and it is usually one of only a few on my boards, over and over in waves.) I also curate my boards periodically – which signals my concern for self-image, I suppose.

I no longer pin or turn to pinterest with the same enthusiasm as I did two years ago + when I started as I am not interested in the fashion or food that dominates the site. I preferred the art/design/architecture bent of the earlier pins and miss them. With the dearth of shelter magazines and the creative burst of design blogs (such as design*sponge) Pinterest is about the only way to hang onto design, interior looks, products or ideas that hold appeal. I realize that says something about me – and acknowledge that I hate to clothes or shoe shop and would just as soon wear a handsome uniform of some sort and turn to my clippings, food blogs and cookbooks for recipes.

Lucy

I think very similarly to you. I ask myself at times if I would dress the same or if people in general would if there was no one to impress.

I think a lot of people, including me, would dress differently if there was no one around to see it, but as for designing, I wouldn’t be much different if zombies took over. I am very affected by my surroundings and if no one in the world ever came to my house again, I would still put a lot of time and energy in designing it. Beauty means so much to me.

The only thing is you second guess yourself at times wondering what company will think of a certain paint color you choose or whatever. So, really for some people, if anything you hold back for fear of others not liking a risky design decision.

As for putting things on display or for show, that depends on why you are doing it. I feel if you are showing off, it’s really a turn off for me and not a motivator behind why I collect things, but if it’s because you genuinely love it or want to entertain others with things you curate, then that’s a whole different ballgame. I think you are right that some people do this, maybe even a lot of people, but definitely not all people.

As for Pinterest, I have had to remind myself that other people may look at my boards at times so I might want to clean them up. Most of the time I forget the public nature of it (it doesn’t feel that public to me, I don’t often look at the entirety of others boards) so I don’t really feel I’m trying to project a persona. Now that you pointed it out though, I feel I should probably try a little harder lol!

Nettie

Thank you for an introspective, thoughtful analysis of social media behavior that is often engaged in without thought or reflection. I am not surprised that some readers found it cynical. The searchlight of analyzing why we do what we do is often quite uncomfortable. Again, thank you. This was a brave topic.

Julia Mukuddem

oh wow – what an incredible interesting read … i’ve got almost 3000 followers … this really makes one think … thanks … hmm …

RD

You know, I’m not sure Pinterest is any different than any social situation – how public you are or how much you like to share is very individual. As a pretty introverted person I dress as much for myself as I do for others and probably pin for myself more than I do for others. It’s not a matter of perception, either. I work at home and dress myself for work every day, even though no one will see me, because I love clothes and love to feel like I look good. And I have a series of public boards on Pinterest that I use less than half as often than the (maximum three) private boards you are allowed- they have twice as many pins per board than all my public boards put together. I create and genuinely cultivate them only for myself. So. I guess I am the person who would actually be weaving daisy crowns after the zombie apocalypse. I’m not sure what that says about me- but I think that at least I am the exception to some of your assumptions- and just for the what-the-hell-is-wrong-with-me? factor – I hope I’m not totally alone! ;) Thank you for a thought provoking article!

Kristyn

I’d like to think that if I were the last human on earth—although my personal style currently is influenced by others on the subway, in the pages of fashion magazines, and on Pinterest—I would continue to care about beautifying my surroundings and reminding myself of better times with art, color, or ornament. Not because others would see it, but because it makes me feel good. Sure, I’d run from zombies, then I’d collect, dream, and try to escape my current reality. My personal style gets a public stage because I travel and interact with others during the day, but if I were housebound it would be just as important.

I’d argue that Pinterest is more of an extended memory bank than a tool for branding my style in the eyes of others. I want to know that idea is waiting for me when I want to renovate, throw a party, or choose an outfit for a job interview. I can conveniently crowd-source great ideas from a pool of people I’ve never met, and once pinned by me, they may help or inspire a friend, or a friend of a friend, as well.

Chris

As a highly visual person I was sure that I would be using Pinterest like a madwoman, but in reality I barely use it. I like the idea of collecting images/links to be able to come back to and visually see them laid out in front of me but I dislike the “visible to all” aspect. I don’t like other people being able to see what I pin. I’m not embarrassed by my pins but I really just don’t like sharing them because I don’t want people to form ideas about me based on them. For me, I use Pinterest like a file folder of things I want to remember, investigate further or for work. I do enjoy looking at other people’s boards, but I guess I’m just more of a private person. I do like that Pinterest has “secret boards” and may use it more now.

Barbara

Great article. Like “LW” (10/24), I use Pinterest less for social reasons than for personal convenience. There are occasions, however, when someone who leads me to a product or image gets a warm and sincere thanks. Those people are few and far between, though, which is, again, what makes Pinterest useful to me. My real friends are few and far between as well; it just makes life purer and simpler. I cancelled my Facebook account for the same reason. The fact that we involve ourselves in a virtual world is not a sound reason to make that world the primary source of our interactions with like-minded (or different, for that matter) people. Of course, D*S readers and writers are, one and all, real people in the best virtual world. *-) Nice to have a moment to hang out here!

Michelle P

As a photographer, I was very hesitant to start using Pinterest, but now I use it exactly as I would a traditional mood board. I only pin things that resonate with me (& am diligent about crediting every pin). Together, my boards really do paint a picture of my aesthetic & having that reference has helped me immensely. As to why make these collections public, honestly – much like getting dressed before heading out in the morning, it’s something about myself that I am willing to share with both friends & strangers. It tells a story about who I am & what I find beautiful or intriguing (even if it’s aspirational) – which of course isn’t the whole story, but I’d argue that it’s a pretty meaty chapter. To me, getting a peek into someone’s aesthetic, feels more intimate than reading about their latest “postable” or “tweetable” activity. It’s like when you walk into someone’s home for the first time, & you pause to take it all in: noticing what sort of art they have on the wall, what they are cooking for dinner, what music they are listening to, etc., all informs you about who that person is -even if it’s ostentatious or artificial.

It’s true, we all live in the same era, are exposed to the same things & our tastes probably aren’t as unique as we think they are. In a zombie apocalypse, function would take precedence & yes, I’d be less concerned with aesthetics, but if the zombies were keeping Pinterest boards, you’d better believe I’d be checking them out!

mlise

Thanks for a very interesting and provocative essay.
As mentioned by you pinning is of course not a basic need. Food, shelter etc are basics, but further up Maslow’s pyramid there’s room for collections of curios/vizuals for one reason or another.
You write: “Whether we want to admit it or not, our impulse to acquire objects to wear and ornament our personal spaces has much more to do with the people who will see them than us personally.”
This is ONE reason for pinning, but it’s exaggerated to seek to argue that pinning is always an extrovert presentation of a persona. (introverts have style too and, I suppose, they may enjoy pinning as well.)
Other purposes served by pinning in my case are to
– help me remember things I find interesting/beautiful/useful/funny
– serve as an aide memoire for a blog etc.
– provide links to info on objects I possess.
Once again, thanks for sharing your views and provoking reactions – now I’ll have a look at the other comments.
All the best, mlise

mo

Spot on! I am often aware of the ability to create my own kunstkammer (thank you for introducing this concept, btw! new to me, and very interesting!) at zero expense (to myself). The “dark underbelly” you refer to…copyright infringement…is unsettling to me as well. I really like Pinterest, but I don’t want to sincerely hurt anyone by using it. Hopefully we can educate ourselves on how to be more responsible/considerate moving forward.

Kathy - Designer Pinboards

I would like to think I would still maintain my personal style when the Zombies come to stay. With a home based office I still ‘dress’ for work, although I must admit it is a variation on the same standard black wardrobe that has served me well for 20+ years.
Seeing my two daughters (10 & 11 yrs) develope their own personal style I would strongly argue that there is something inate rather than environmental. One is sleek, stylish and able to coordinate colours and clothes with ease. The other is like a spring garden in full bloom, every colour and style worn at once! A true explosion of delight.
I too use Pinterest for both my business and personal account. To me it is a great way to record where I am, where I have been (chevron pattern anyone?) and where I would like to go. Whether that is the next holiday destination or the next big design trend. I like the original spirit of Pinterest and tend to favour pins that don’t have the branding and price tags. And of course I have actual real Pinboards everywhere to pin my personal inspiration that is for my (& family/friends) eyes only.

Lori

Like some of the others, I don’t choose what I do pin to impress others, but I definitely EDIT what I put up there. I treat all social media the same way. The measure is “would I ever want to take this back?”. If so then it doesn’t go out. This doesn’t mean that I present an inauthentic, homogenized picture, it actually forces me to really focus on what’s important enough to me to put out there and own. It was a great day when the private boards debuted- just wish you could have more of them.

I love these topics and thoughtful way you have been exploring personal philosophies etc. DS has always been an intriguing space, but you are taking it to the next level.

Paula Mills

Great article, thanks. To me the biggest plus to Pinterest is the time it SAVES. Prior to pinterest I would have to trawl for ages through the web finding like minded images/styles/influences/inspiration etc. but now with Pinterest, as I only follow pinners whose style I admire, I have narrowed my search and am instantly inspired every time I look at my Pinterest home page. I think it is brilliant – and has been brilliant for my on line creative business. To quote Alian De Botton, ‘aesthetics are key to our wellbeing’ I would think I would need beauty ESPECIALLY in a world full of zombies!

Jess Gerrow

I had no idea that posting photos from external sources was in direct violation of Pinterest’s terms and conditions! I had, on the contrary, always assumed that posting photos that you actually you owned was quite taboo – a form of self promotion that is, at best, only just tolerated by Pinterest users.

I loved this thoughtful, well researched essay. (I’m a former art history student, so I would ;) I also love when I find other people who have deeper thoughts about social media and design than one might discuss in 140 characters or less.

I acknowledge the social nature of Pinterest, but I do belong to the (small?) group of users who would actually pay to use Pinterest to bookmark things privately, if I could. The current three ‘private’ boards are not enough.

Unfortunately (as a graduate with two masters degrees in marketing) I know that it would impact Pinterest’s bottom line, as its monetization model moves towards integrated advertising and promotional content, rather than a subscription based model.

But hey, if any Pinterest execs ever read this…
;)

GumTreeGirl

I actually wish pinterest let you have more hidden boards. I like my public boards but sometimes I am working on a project that I am not ready to share with the world yet and the ability to have more hidden boards would be great.

Sue

Before Pinterest I would bookmark those things I loved and tried or wanted to keep so I could try them later, like the cute but simple skirt I made for my grand-daughter a few years ago. I had always wished there was a place that I could keep patterns, pictures that inspired me and the home page to blogs I loved to read. Bookmarking is good but it is hard to arrange. Now with Pinterest I have easy access to those things.

Another thing I love about it is how many of the women in my church use it. One of our Pastor’s does the Women’s Christmas party each year. This is no small tea it is a bigger than life all out party like you might see at a celebrity house. Last years we have a live Nativity scene complete with camels. So she pins ideas for the party months in advance as she is working out the details to put into action.

Other women pin baby things when they are pregnant, or lunch ideas in August so they can be armed with tasty, healthy foods for school lunches, and the teacher at my church and in the community pin ideas to help them be better teacher.

I love Pinterest. I get ideas and insights to those I know from Church and community and I can pin what I like. I did feel that I had started pinning like a mad woman there for a while and have cut back. I have also arranged my boards better to be more useful and feel it could use more tweaking. One of my boards has little use and this has bothered me so I am going to remedy that soon. The title of the board is Stop pinning and start trying. I want to actually use the board as it is intended and not just keep things for the sake of keeping.

I do have almost completely stopped going to the local library for old magazines to tear inspirations pages out of. Now my stacks of inspiration are on-line instead of looking like notebooks of kindling in my sewing/craft room.

Melissa S.

The social aspect is actually part of my frustration with Pinterest. I want to see what everyone else pins, and I want to curate ideas for my own home and personal style, but when I actually pin, 90% of the time it’s to a private board.

I’m not sure why I’m reluctant to share all the things I’m finding and liking.

I think, recognizing that Pinterest is superficial, I’m afraid of being labeled. If I pin that cabinet, people will put me into a shabby chic box, and if I pin that DIY project, people will think I’m a certain kind of home-crafty person, or maybe if I pin the Eames chair, they’ll put me into a separate kind of elite-fashion box. So I pin it all to my private boards so that…what? What comes after that?

Perhaps Pinterest seems more like a guilty, unattainable pleasure than anything else, dancing dangerously close to a lie. Is it just “inspiration”? Is it helping to compile my personal style? Can I make a statement about a personal style that’s only in my head? Is having a “personal style” really that important anyway? Can it even be called personal style if everyone else on Pinterest seems to have the same sort of style? Is pinning akin to pornography?

I may be over-thinking Pinterest.

Raquel

I find that while I am new to Pintrest (going on 2-3 months) I love that I get to put up mood boards that inspire my current state of life and personal style. Everything from eating better, feeling better, exercise, dressing better. Yes I pin these extravagant pieces I can’t afford and they are all over the place because well, my future decor depends on what the space calls for, the occasion dictates the outfit, etc but it inspires me to do what I am doing right now better. Annie Dillard said, “How you live your days is how you live your life.” I am all about streamlining and digitizing the inspirational mood board, rather than tearing images and wasting paper, I access them online and modify as necessary, streamline as I get closer to that reality. It reminds me to buy fresh flowers from time to time, how to wear that old sweater I am bored to tears with in a fresh way, to innovate with my meals, to bake more!

As to the social component, it allows me to keep all of the blogs that inspire me together in one place in a visually appealing way. The big picture aspect. And at the same time I feel that I am bonding with other friends and acquaintances on pintrest over our castles in the air of the lives we want to lead. A kind of support group in achieving a certain lifestyle and just being fabulous together! I find that with people I was once not so close with, we now have this common bond: progress to discuss when we do meet up.

Leah

I decided to use Pinterest because it was a way to remember where a got said image in the first place. I was doing what I do on pinterest before but saving the images to my personal computer and getting frustrated that I couldn’t remember the source. So pinterest helped me save room and find the source. I was a little apprehensive at first because others could see what I was pinning but I got over it and now find it interesting what other people respond to. Funny thing is I think even in a zombie apocalypse I would take a moment, when I found a safe place to make my space feel more homey. I can’t help myself I’m selfish, I do it for me.

Christina

Really really good article! I have often looked at my pins and thought, “Damn, my Pinterest makes me look cool.” And then I laugh at myself but it’s the honest to god truth. I’m on a very low income… but I DO have good taste, I swear! Pinterest (and similarly my blog) allow me to explore and express that taste, and I’ve wondered if that amounts to me being terribly farcical or if it can be shrugged off as just having fun.

I will note that while the social nature of Pinterest is huge to its success and I definitely agree that if I was the last human on earth I would probably lose interest in expressing my personal style… I must also say that I do still value ways of saving images online that are not shared with the world. I used Zootool and when that started going defunct switched to Clipular, which has an interface very similar to Pinterest but the default setting is private. You CAN share boards you just don’t have to. Pinterest’s three secret boards are much more limiting. I use Clipular to save all the stuff that I want to remember, to reference back to, to be inspired by, to buy at a later date, but that I don’t feel the need to share. Honestly, I think I’ve branded my Pinterest, and if I want to save an image that doesn’t fit in my brand, it goes to Clipular. WEIRD, right? It doesn’t help that I have my Pinterest account assoicated with my blog, so I really only want high quality, well curated images on my Pinterest. OBVIOUSLY I’m not pinning just for myself.

You really got me thinking, sir! :)

LEAVE A COMMENT