
Today’s Biz Ladies post comes from Karen Kobelski, general manager of BizFilings, an online incorporation provider. While we have previously covered the topic of incorporation, this post delves deeper into the details of incorporation, including the various types of incorporation you can choose from and the best location for your incorporation. Thanks, Karen, for such an informative post! — Stephanie
Read the full post after the jump . . .
Hi! I’m Karen Kobelski, and I’m going to share a bit of useful information about incorporation and other essential things to know as you start your small business. As general manager of BizFilings, an online incorporation provider, I’m proud to provide support to the millions of entrepreneurs in America following their dreams. We’ve incorporated hundreds of thousands of businesses, and it’s been such a joy to see the range of business ideas over the years. There are some really creative people (like you!) out there.
Why do I need to incorporate?
So, why is incorporation important? We get this question a lot. Many people operate their business as a sole proprietorship (which isn’t necessarily wrong). Being a sole proprietor may make sense for those starting out because it’s less expensive in the short term than incorporating. What being a sole proprietor doesn’t provide, however, is any liability protection between your personal assets and your business risks — and if things go wrong, this can be the most expensive scenario of all.
Imagine you’ve started a bakery, and someone sues your business (perhaps for something simple and seemingly innocuous — remember the famous McDonald’s lawsuit over the fact that hot coffee is, indeed, hot?). Even if you’re found not to be in the wrong, you’re still likely to incur up to thousands of dollars in legal fees. If you were incorporated, your home, car and personal assets would be covered under liability protection and couldn’t be seized to pay these legal fees, but if you were a sole proprietor, these assets may be fair game. It’s heartbreaking; you’ve spent years saving and building your personal assets, and without liability protection, they can be taken away to settle business debts.
Picking the “right” kind of incorporation
Another question we get asked a lot is what kind of incorporation is the “right” or “best” one. The simple answer is that there’s no single kind of incorporation that is “right” for everyone. Our most popular kinds of incorporations are LLCs (limited liability companies), C corporations and S corporations — these make up over 90 percent of our business formations. You can also choose to have a business entity, such as a nonprofit corporation, LLP (limited liability partnership) or PLLC (professional limited liability company), but these aren’t as common.
To decide which type of business formation is right for you, you’ll need to consider your particular ownership structure and future business plans (e.g., do you plan to go public or continue being privately held?), as well as analyze your tax considerations.
Knowing your audience (in terms of lenders) can also be important. If you’re interested in raising money through venture capitalists, these tend to prefer investing in C corporations. Also, if you eventually want to be publicly traded, be aware that you’ll have to be formed as a C corp at that time.
Different formations offer different kinds of tax savings. An owner of an S corp or C corp who is also an employee can minimize self-employment taxes by taking a more modest (yet appropriate) salary and taking more business earnings as income, which is not subject to self-employment taxes. With an LLC, there is no distinction between salary and income, so all of the owner’s income is subject to self-employment taxes. Both LLCs and S corps offer pass-through taxation, which means there is no income tax paid at a business level; instead, the profits and losses of your business are reported on your personal tax return, and any tax due on business income is paid at an individual level.
Because there are so many choices, we offer an Incorporation Wizard and business-type comparison table that explain the differences between business types and help entrepreneurs determine which formation is best for their business.
I’m ready to incorporate (and finally picked a type), but what state is best?
After choosing your business formation type, you’ll need to decide where you should incorporate your business. Where to incorporate is another common source of confusion. Often, people think that they should incorporate in Delaware or Nevada because they’ve heard it’s “less expensive.” And it’s true that these two states are popular for incorporation, but they have hidden traps.
For example, if you incorporate in Delaware or Nevada but operate your “brick-and-mortar” business in another state, you’ll also have to register your business in that state, and that means you’ll have to pay filing fees (and have ongoing compliance obligations) to your business’ home state as well as to the “cheaper” Delaware or Nevada. This can mean that incorporating in Delaware or Nevada actually requires you to pay twice the fees and do twice the work. It’s true that incorporating in Delaware or Nevada makes sense for some (we’ve written about the reasons for this at BizFilings.com), but most of the time, it doesn’t really save you money when you’re getting started.
I’ve heard about foreign qualification for my business, but what does that mean? I’m still selling in the US, right?
Once you establish a physical presence or hire an employee in a state other than the state where you incorporated, you need to qualify your business in that state. This is called “foreign qualification.” You must register (foreign qualify) your business with any state where you have “nexus,” which is defined as having employees, property and/or some other tangible presence in the state. “Foreign qualification” has nothing to do with leaving the country — it simply means that you’ve established “nexus” outside of the state in which you originally incorporated your business. It gives your “foreign” business a legal right to do business in a state other than where the company was formed. So if you form in Wisconsin, but you hire a salesperson in Minnesota, your domestic Wisconsin corporation/LLC should be foreign qualified in Minnesota.
Foreign qualifying your company is important because if you don’t, you can be fined, held liable for back taxes and lose access to that state’s court system in the case of a lawsuit. Often, these consequences can be much more expensive than the cost of foreign qualification.
Once you’ve picked a business formation and the state you want to incorporate in (or states, if you’re growing and expanding), you’re set to succeed with your small business! Of course, there are ongoing compliance issues, end-of-year reports and more, but that’s for another post!
I hope this overview has helped you decide what kind of business formation is right for you and answered some of the questions that we often get. Remember that the information provided here is general in nature and is not intended to replace the counsel of an attorney. If you’re interested in learning more about what I’ve explained or have other questions about incorporation or compliance for your small business, I’ll happily take your questions via the comments section below. Or you can use our Small Business Roundtable on the BizFilings’ Facebook page, where each Wednesday we take questions from entrepreneurs and have experts answer them via video.
13 Comments
I wish you’d included a FB “Share” button. Great info.
Incorporating a small business, while it may be a good idea for many reasons, does not always offer complete personal asset protection as suggested in this post. Frequently, an incorporated entity and the individual that owns it will be named jointly as defendants in a lawsuit. Additionally, most lenders and landlords will require a personal guarantee on loans and leases. Getting sued on a personal guarantee will put personal assets at risk if the judgment creditor tries to collect its judgment.
Additionally, Stella Liebeck did not receive a judgment against McDonald’s just because it served hot coffee. There are many websites (and a documentary called Hot Coffee) that describe the facts of the case and why Ms. Liebeck was awarded damages at trial.
Thank you for the information about foreign qualifications. I will keep that in mind if I have to move out of state.
I operate as an LLC and it was pretty easy to file with the state since I am the only member. Under the advise of a lawyer, I made sure my business bank accounts are filed with an Employer Identification Number instead of my social security. This adds further distinction between personal and business accounts.
I also made sure that at the bottom of my contracts, where I sign, it says my name and underneath “president of Dorig Designs LLC” so that it is clear to clients they are contracting with an LLC and not just an individual person.
These posts are so informative! In general, the Biz Ladies series is brilliant…it offers some of the best free business advice on the web! Thanks ladies.
So informative, thanks! I’m currently trying to decide between a sole proprietorship and an LLC. Are there any good reasons to other than liability that it’s a good idea?
this is great info! when i set up my business, my partner and i did everything wrong that we possibly could have. eventually (a year and $2000 later) we figured it out. i guess there’s no better way to learn than to make mistakes…
I’m kicking around the idea of incorporating my design business and am wondering the same thing as Anni, are there any other benefits other than liability protection?
great post!! i have set up as a sole proprietor, though maybe its different here. i will definitely look into it now though!
just to set the record straight, people often quote the maccas case when referring to frivolous lawsuits (and i did too!!), but it actually wasn’t frivolous at all: http://www.lectlaw.com/files/cur78.htm
I feel I need to clarify a statement in the article above re: LLCs and taxation. The statement should read, “With an LLC *taxed as a disregarded entity*, there is no distinction between salary and income, so all of the owner’s income is subject to self-employment taxes.” When forming an LLC, however, you can elect how the LLC will be taxed – as a “disregarded entity,” an “S-Corp,” a “C-Corp,” or a “partnership.” This is one of the great aspects of the LLC in addition to the liability protection. When an LLC elects to be taxed as an S-Corp, the statement above is not accurate and the tax result is different and the owner/member can take advantage of the S-Corp taxation benefits.
In many states, the LLC also is cheaper to form, maintain, and requires less in the way of record keeping. Many states require that corporations file annual reports (along with an annual fee) and the corporate record keeping (minutes, resolutions, etc) involved with a corporation is also more cumbersome.
Finally, there is an enormous difference in the liability protection provided by a corporation and an LLC. Do not underestimate this. The LLC (or PLLC) offers much better protection than the corporate structure.
Please consult with an attorney and CPA prior to setting up your business. You don’t know what you don’t know and can spend much more time and money fixing or converting your entity later than you would setting it up correctly from the start. Buy an hour or two of an attorney’s time and get good information.
I just love this series. Even when it doesn’t apply directly to me, I typically find the posts so interesting and helpful. Thanks for sharing your wisdom!
I really love Biz Ladies! I find them very interesting and inspirational. YAY for ladies!
Thanks for all of the great comments and the additional clarification about the LLC with S Corp status. To add to that point, many people do not know they can elect S Corp status when they form an LLC. We have a great article about this on our Business Owner’s Toolkit site – http://www.toolkit.com/news/newsDetail.aspx?nid=10-247LLCSCorp which provides more detail about this “best of both worlds” option.
To answer the other questions about what other reasons might there be beyond liability protection for incorporating – there are a quite a few. One of the main advantages is that it provides access to investment capital. Most investors will not be comfortable investing in a sole proprietorship because there is no tangible evidence of their formal “stake” in the company. If you can issue stock in a corporation or a membership certificate in the LLC, you can establish an ownership interest for the investor. Additionally, if you are seeking a small business loan, most banks prefer to lend to a legally registered business rather than making a business loan to an individual.
Finally – it’s a question of credibility, incorporating your business shows investors, customers and suppliers that you have made a formal commitment to your business. Many sole proprietors have to fight the perception that they are just dabbling in something. Incorporating says: “I’m committed”. That goes a long way when you are trying to get your business off the ground. Please let me know if I can answer any more questions.
This came at perfect timing. Thank you!
Leave a Comment